HONG KONG — An electronics manufacturer in Taiwan said Wednesday that it did not make the pagers used by members of the militant group Hezbollah that exploded simultaneously across Lebanon on Tuesday, killing at least nine people.
More than 2,750 others were injured in the blasts, according to Lebanon’s health ministry, including Iran’s ambassador to Lebanon. In a statement on Wednesday, Iran-backed Hezbollah said there would be a “severe reckoning” over the blasts, for which it blamed Israel without providing evidence.
Israel has not commented directly on the explosions.
Images circulating online show destroyed pagers in Lebanon whose features are consistent with those made by Taiwan-based Gold Apollo. The company’s founder and president, Hsu Ching-kuang, told reporters on Wednesday that the pagers were made by another company licensed to use its brand.
“There is an agent in Europe whom we have cooperated with for three years, they are the agent for all of our products,” Hsu said at the company’s offices in the northern Taiwanese city of New Taipei.
“We are not a big company, but we are a responsible company that cares about our products,” he said.
In a statement, Gold Apollo identified the other company as the Hungary-based BAC Consulting. The company is authorized to used Gold Apollo’s logo for product sales in certain regions, “but the design and manufacturing of the products are entirely handled by BAC,” the statement said.
Reached by phone on Wednesday, BAC Consulting chief executive Cristiana Bársony-Arcidiacono confirmed that her company worked with Gold Apollo. But when asked about the pagers and the explosions, she said, “I don’t make the pagers. I am just the intermediate. I think you got it wrong.”
A spokesperson for Gold Apollo declined to comment further on Wednesday, citing the ongoing investigation.
Taiwan’s Ministry of Economic Affairs said Wednesday that Gold Apollo had exported 260,000 pagers from 2022 to August 2024, primarily to European and American markets. In a statement, it said there had been no reports of explosions related to those products and that there were no records of the company exporting pagers directly to Lebanon.
“Was this batch of goods actually modified? … Did another manufacturer produce them and simply label them with the Apollo brand? This part is still under investigation by the authorities,” a ministry spokesperson told NBC News.
The explosions on Tuesday come amid rising concern that tensions between Israel and Lebanon could spiral into all-out war. Israel and Hezbollah, which is based in Lebanon and opposes Israel’s assault on the Gaza Strip, have been engaged in cross-border attacks since the start of the Israel-Hamas war last October, displacing thousands of people in both countries.
Lebanon’s foreign ministry condemned what it called an “Israeli cyber attack,” saying that it would lodge a complaint with the U.N. Security Council.
Jeanine Hennis-Plasschaert, the U.N. special coordinator for Lebanon, said Tuesday that the explosions marked “an extremely concerning escalation in what is an already unacceptably volatile context.”
State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller said Tuesday that the U.S. was “not aware of this incident in advance” and not involved in it.
Videos suggest that explosive devices were integrated into the pagers, said N.R. Jenzen-Jones, the director of Armament Research Services, a technical intelligence consulting firm.
“The scale suggests a complex supply-chain attack, rather than a scenario in which devices were intercepted and modified in transit,” he said on X.
Pagers are favored by members of Hezbollah who avoid using cellphones for fear that Israel could use them to track and monitor them. Lebanese officials warned all citizens on Tuesday to stay away from their wireless communication devices pending further notice.
Hezbollah said it was investigating the explosions and that there would be a “severe reckoning that the criminal enemy must face for the massacre it committed on Tuesday against our people, our families and our fighters in Lebanon.”
The group said earlier that “a girl and two brothers” were among those killed by the explosions, some of which appeared to have been captured on closed-circuit TV video and shared on social media. Muhammad Mahdi, the son of Ali Ammar, a Hezbollah member of Parliament, was also reportedly killed.
Hsu of Gold Apollo said he also felt he had been victimized and was considering filing a lawsuit.
“I am a businessman,” he said. “How did I get involved in this attack?”
### Insights
#### Potential Supply Chain Vulnerabilities
The incident with the pagers highlights potential vulnerabilities in the global supply chain when it comes to the manufacturing and distribution of electronic devices. It raises questions about ensuring oversight and quality control when products are outsourced to external entities for production.
#### Geopolitical Implications
The accusations and finger-pointing between Hezbollah, Israel, and Lebanon following the explosions not only exacerbate regional tensions but also have broader geopolitical implications. The situation underscores the fragility of relations in the Middle East and the potential for escalation.
#### Security Concerns
The use of pagers by Hezbollah members due to security concerns highlights the ongoing technological challenges in surveillance and monitoring in conflict zones. It showcases the lengths to which certain groups must go to protect their communications from external interception.
